When One Year Becomes a Calling: Sue Lehman on 17 Years of Leadership at Hope House
Sue Lehman never expected a one year opportunity to become the defining chapter of the second half of her career.
After spending roughly 20 years in the for profit world, Sue was ready for a change when she was approached about leading a pilot project at Hope House in Findlay, Ohio. She accepted the position believing she would give it a year, see where it went, and then decide what came next. Seventeen years later, that temporary opportunity had grown into a career in nonprofit leadership and a deeply personal connection to an organization dedicated to helping people find stability during some of the most difficult periods of their lives.
In this episode of Women in the Driver Seat, host Mary Helen Darah and Taylor Automotive Family Community Ambassador Joan Browne Kose visit Hope House to sit down with Sue as she prepares for retirement. Their conversation explores the unexpected path that led her into nonprofit work, the changing realities surrounding homelessness, and the lessons she has learned about compassion, teamwork, leadership, and believing in the potential of others.
A Career Path She Never Planned
Sue is quick to admit that becoming CEO of Hope House was never part of a carefully mapped out career plan. She enjoyed the first half of her professional life, but after two decades she felt ready to explore something new.
The opportunity at Hope House arrived at exactly that point. Sue was asked to lead a one year pilot program and approached the decision with an open mind. If it worked, she would see where it led. If it did not, she would move on.
The program became successful enough to develop into one of Hope House’s core programs for several years, and Sue’s role continued growing with it. She eventually became program director, then assistant director, and later CEO. Looking back, she can now see a connection between what initially seemed like two very different careers.
“I have always been drawn to helping people recognize their potential and giving them the tools and support that they need to figure that out and to move forward,” Sue explains.
That desire to help people move forward became central to her work at Hope House.
Helping People Find Stability
Hope House has served the Findlay and Hancock County community for more than 35 years.
What began as a shelter for women and children has expanded significantly over time and now serves men, women, older adults, veterans, young adults, and families experiencing homelessness or housing instability.
The organization provides shelter services, rental assistance, permanent supportive housing, education, and other resources designed to help people move toward a more stable future.
Sue has also watched that work become more complicated during her 17 years with the organization. Affordable housing has become increasingly difficult to find, while the rising costs of groceries, utilities, transportation, and other necessities continue stretching household budgets.
Those challenges mean the people coming to Hope House often need more than a temporary place to stay. They may need assistance navigating housing options, financial support, education, or simply someone willing to help them take the next step.
Even with those growing challenges, Sue says the rewarding moments have always outweighed the difficult ones.
When Former Clients Come Back to Give
Some of Sue’s favorite moments happen long after a client has completed a program at Hope House.
Former clients occasionally return carrying household supplies or kitchen items. Others come back with a financial donation. They are no longer walking through the doors because they need help. They are returning because they are finally in a position to provide it.
For Sue, those moments are among the clearest signs that the work matters.
A person who once relied on Hope House during one of the darkest periods of their life has rebuilt enough stability to help someone else facing a similar situation.
“What they’re really saying is that you were here for me during some of my darkest times, and now I’m in a position where I can pay that forward,” Sue says.
Those experiences have also changed Sue personally. She entered nonprofit work believing she was already a compassionate person, but 17 years of hearing people’s stories and watching them rebuild their lives broadened her perspective in ways she never expected.
Leadership Requires Both Head and Heart
Sue believes nonprofit leadership requires a balance between compassion and clear thinking. The work can be incredibly rewarding, but it is also complicated, and good intentions alone are not enough.
Her advice to women interested in nonprofit leadership is to bring both their head and their heart into the work.
She also believes leadership does not mean having every answer. Strong leaders surround themselves with capable people, build relationships, trust their teams, and create an environment where others can recognize and use their own abilities.
That philosophy has shaped the way Sue has led Hope House.
“There’s not just one path to get into this work,” she says. Everything she learned during the first half of her career eventually became useful during the second.
Her experience is a reminder that changing directions professionally does not mean starting over. Skills, relationships, and lessons from previous roles often become part of what makes someone successful in the next one.
Knowing What Matters Most
One of Sue’s strongest pieces of advice for other women is to understand their values and remain true to them.
Careers change. Opportunities appear unexpectedly. Leadership brings difficult decisions.
Having a clear understanding of what matters most provides something steady to return to when those situations arise.
For Sue, much of that has centered on recognizing potential in other people.
Whether working with a client, developing a staff member, or leading an organization, she believes people need opportunities to use their strengths and contribute.
The same thinking shapes her view of teamwork. Sue says leaders benefit from the knowledge and experience of the people around them, and organizations are strongest when the right people are trusted to do what they do well.
“We can’t do this work by ourselves,” she says. “It takes the right people in the right positions.”
Looking Back With Gratitude
As retirement approaches, Sue says she has spent a great deal of time reflecting on the past 17 years.
The word that continually comes to mind is gratitude.
She is grateful for the people she has worked alongside, for the Findlay community, and for the unexpected opportunity that brought her to Hope House in the first place.
While leadership at the organization will change, Sue is confident that the values behind the work will remain. She plans to stay connected and continue supporting Hope House even after stepping away from her role as CEO.
Retirement will bring new adventures as well, including a planned trip to Australia and New Zealand. But Hope House will remain an important part of her story.
What began as a one year pilot project became 17 years of leadership, relationships, challenges, and moments that showed Sue just how much people can accomplish when they are given the right support.
Her career did not follow the path she originally imagined.
It led somewhere more meaningful.
👉 Watch now to hear Sue Lehman reflect on 17 years at Hope House, the people who shaped her journey, and why compassion, teamwork, and believing in others have remained at the heart of her leadership.




Comments