top of page

Growing With the Community: Chelsea Sheeter on 16 Years at The Wine Merchant

Nov 6
5 min read

A longtime local business can become part of the story of a community.


Customers grow up.


Families celebrate milestones.


New traditions take shape.


And sometimes the people working behind the counter grow right alongside the business itself.


That has been the experience for Chelsea Sheeter, who has spent the past 16 years at The Wine Merchant in downtown Findlay.


In this episode of Women in the Driver Seat, host Mary Helen Darah and Taylor Automotive Family Community Ambassador Joan Browne Kose visit The Wine Merchant to talk with Chelsea about the changing business, the relationships that have kept her there, and what she has learned from helping a local favorite navigate everything from a neighboring fire to the COVID era.


Chelsea originally came to The Wine Merchant as a server.


Today, she plays a major management role in a business that has become much more than a place to purchase a bottle of wine.


Finding a Place for Creativity


Chelsea joined The Wine Merchant in 2010 after a friend who already worked there encouraged her to apply.


She had previously worked at Waldo Peppers downtown and arrived with experience in restaurants, but she quickly discovered The Wine Merchant was different.


Even as a server, the job required flexibility.


The business combined retail sales with food and bar service, which meant employees needed to be comfortable moving between roles.


A customer might need help choosing wine.


Someone else might be ordering food.


Another person could be asking about beer or an upcoming event.


Chelsea learned all of it.


Over time, that variety became one of the reasons she loved the work.


Chelsea studied art at Bowling Green State University and has always considered herself a hands on, creative person.


At The Wine Merchant, she found unexpected ways to use that creativity.


She has designed chalkboards and menus, worked on social media, developed food pairings, planned events, and helped customers turn their own ideas into something special.


The work gave her an outlet she did not necessarily expect to find in hospitality.


Becoming More Than a Wine Shop


The Wine Merchant itself has continued changing during Chelsea’s years there.


She describes a business with a long history in Findlay, including different owners and locations over the years.


Under current owner Dan Matheny, its offerings have expanded considerably.


Wine remains at the center, but customers can also discover gourmet foods, specialty products, catering, retail items, and carefully planned dining experiences.


The shop has even grown into selling items such as seafood, steaks, and other foods Chelsea never would have imagined being part of the business when she first started.


That evolution has helped The Wine Merchant become more of a destination.


Someone might stop in for a bottle of wine and leave with ingredients for dinner.


Another customer may be planning a catered celebration.


Someone else may come for an event or simply sit down and enjoy the atmosphere.

For Chelsea, that constant evolution keeps the job interesting.


There is always another flavor to discover or another way to create something customers will enjoy.


Starting Over After a Fire


Not every change has come by choice.


One of the most difficult moments Chelsea remembers came after a neighboring fire.


Although The Wine Merchant itself remained, the conditions created by the fire compromised the store’s wine inventory.


Suddenly, years of carefully selected products had to be evaluated and replaced.


Chelsea remembers months spent working through insurance claims and documenting everything throughout the business.


It was exhausting.


There was also something emotional about watching so much inventory disappear at once.

Then came the challenge of reopening.


The Wine Merchant had to rebuild and find its rhythm again.


Years later, another major disruption arrived with COVID.


Once again, the business had to adapt.


Rather than simply waiting for things to return to normal, the team started thinking differently about what customers needed.


They expanded their food offerings and worked toward becoming more of a one stop destination.


Customers could pick up a great bottle of wine along with food for dinner, allowing them to make fewer stops during a difficult period.


Some of those changes stayed.


Chelsea looks back on both experiences as moments when the business had to reinvent itself and keep moving.


Watching Customers Grow Alongside the Business


Ask Chelsea about the most rewarding part of her work, and she does not start with wine.

She starts with people.


After 16 years, many customers feel more like family.


She has watched families return week after week.


She remembers children who once came in with their parents for pizza and who are now adults returning to choose wine for their own weddings.


Those relationships make the years visible in a way few other things can.


Chelsea has grown with the customers, and the customers have grown with The Wine Merchant.


That connection becomes especially noticeable during busy seasons.


Thanksgiving, Christmas, and wedding season can mean long days and exhausting shifts.


But Chelsea remembers owner Dan Matheny offering a different way to look at those moments.


The food and wine leaving the shop will soon be sitting on someone's family table.


The team may have provided part of a Thanksgiving dinner or the bottle of wine people will share while celebrating together.


Thinking about that makes the long day feel different.


The Wine Merchant is not simply selling something.


In a small way, it becomes part of those memories.


Supporting Findlay Beyond the Store


That sense of connection also influences how The Wine Merchant approaches the Findlay community.


Chelsea talks about donating time and food to charitable efforts, participating in local events, and finding ways to support organizations throughout the area.


Sometimes that means providing products for a fundraiser.


Other times it means donating the team’s time or expertise.


The specific contribution may change, but the larger idea remains the same.


A local business depends on its community.


Supporting that community in return is part of the relationship.


Chelsea sees that same spirit throughout downtown Findlay.


She grew up on another side of town and did not spend much time downtown when she was younger.


Today, she sees something completely different.


Families walk the streets together.


People move between shops.


Businesses support each other.


Downtown has become a place where people intentionally spend time.


That sense of community is one of Chelsea’s favorite things about Findlay.


Keep Moving Forward


Chelsea did not begin at The Wine Merchant knowing exactly where the job would lead.

She started as a server.


Sixteen years later, she has helped guide the business through growth, setbacks, reinvention, and plenty of busy holiday seasons.


Along the way, she found a career that allows her to combine creativity with something she values just as much: relationships.


Her advice to other women trying to find their own path reflects what she has learned through those years.


Keep trying.


Give it your all.


Understand that things will not always work exactly the way you imagined.

And keep moving forward anyway.


That philosophy has served Chelsea well.


It has also helped The Wine Merchant remain a familiar part of Findlay while continuing to become something new.


👉 Watch now to hear Chelsea Sheeter share how 16 years at The Wine Merchant have taught her about creativity, resilience, customer relationships, and growing alongside the Findlay community.


Chelsea Sheeter joins Mary Helen Darah and Joan Browne Kose to share how 16 years at The Wine Merchant have shaped her career and helped a beloved Findlay business continue to evolve.

Comments


bottom of page